Can you tell if someone has the Holy Spirit?

    From BelieveTheSign
    Click on headings to expand them, or links to go to specific articles.

    Can you tell whether someone has the Holy Ghost? William Branham clearly was conflicted here because he couldn't seem to make up his mind.

    No - you can't tell

    From a question posed to William Branham:

    12. Brother Branham, I want to know the place where I can tie down and say "This man has the Holy Ghost because he did this, or this woman has the Holy Ghost because she did that."

    To which William Branham responded:

    There's not a way in the world for you to know it. That's right. There's not a way in the world for you to know it. God is the Judge; we are not to judge. See? [1]

    Yes - you can tell... or at least William Branham could

    In 1959, William Branham statedL

    31 You let me talk to a man two minutes; I can tell you whether he's received the Holy Ghost or not. So can you. It separates them; It's a Mark; It's a Sign. And the Holy Spirit is a Sign. [2]

    And then in 1962, he said:

    I have many Anglican friends who has the Holy Ghost. I have many Methodists… I just helped lead four hundred Lutherans to the baptism of the Holy Ghost. See? And so there's a whole Bethany College received the Holy Ghost at one time. So, see, it—it's not a—an organization, it's an experience for anybody that wishes it.[3]

    Yes - you can tell by the fruits of the Spirit

    In 1963, it was clear that William Branham believed that the presence of the fruits of the Spirit indicated whether a person had the Holy Spirit or not:

    You see, that's the reason I have different with the move of the Pentecostal brethren in that manner that they say, "If a man speaks in tongues, he has the Holy Ghost." I different. That's no sign he's got the Holy Ghost. See? I've heard devils speak with tongues just as fast as they could, drink blood out of a human skull, and call on the devil. 245 I've seen Indians take snakes and wrap around them in the—in the—in the rain dance out there in Arizona, hold their hands up like that, and run right around; the witch doctor come out lancing himself, and lay a pencil down, and it write in unknown tongues and give the interpretation. So, see? So don't—don't tell me that. No, I'm too old for that. See? So… The—the fruit of the Spirit is the… Jesus said, "By their fruits (not tongues or emotions, but) by their fruits ye shall know them." So that is the fruit of the Spirit. It's God unfolding Himself in humility, sweetness, and every day the same. It's something about a man that stays right with the Word, every time that he sees the Word, he punctuates it with an "Amen," no matter what the other people say. That's… He believes it. You see?[4]

    No - the fruits of the Spirit aren't the indicator

    Just 10 months later, in January 1964, William Branham again changes his mind:

    147 "Who is going to stand by you and bury you when you're dead? That kind old priest. He has got the fruit of the Spirit. But does this Jesus of Nazareth have the fruit of the Spirit?" You can't judge by speaking in tongues, neither can you judge by the fruit of the Spirit. But it's a manifestation of the Word of God, brought to Light. It's the Light that does it. The man that walks in that Light! Jesus Christ was not founding upon speaking in tongues, though He did it. He was not the fruit of the Spirit, though He did. You couldn't judge it. But He believed and punctuated It, and God lived every Word of the promise of that day through Him. That's the Light of the hour. That's the evidence. [5]

    Yes - the evidence of the Holy Spirit is believing William Branham

    A month later, William Branham appears to have changed his mind once again.

    This time he pointed to himself as the only way to receive the Holy Spirit. Not the fruits of the Spirit, not simply believing and accepting the Spirit of Christ as was promised to all believers. You have to believe William Branham. Is that really scriptural?

    And if someone says they believe William Branham but covers up the sexual abuse of a minor (as the pastor did in the church we attended), do they have the Holy Spirit? You think????

    Who has the fruit of the Spirit there? See? There you are. See, not fruit of the Spirit, not speaking in tongues, not shouting. 22 You say, "Then, Brother Branham, what is the evidence? What is the evidence?" The vindication of the Word in the hour.[6]
    And there it is. You CAN'T claim that manifestation is the evidence of being Spirit-born, Spirit-filled. No sir. I will admit that true manifestation is the evidence of the Holy Spirit doing mighty acts, but it is NOT the evidence of the individual being Spirit-filled, even though that individual has an abundance of those manifestations. The evidence of receiving the Holy Ghost today is just the same as it was back in the day of our Lord. It is receiving the Word of truth for the day in which you live. Jesus never did stress the importance of the Works as He did the Word. He knew that if the people got the WORD the works would follow. That is Bible.[7]

    Wait... I was wrong... Yes, you can tell by the fruits of the Spirit

    Just prior to William Branham's death, he appears to have reverted to saying that the fruits of the Spirit are key:

    It's what I was trying to say last night, that spirit can be baptized into that Spirit and still not be a Christian. See? You're living right off of the same Life, but the fruits you bear tells what you are. See? That's right. See? They can do all the signs, and pray for the sick, and heal the sick, and open eyes, and cast out devils, and—and do all these things, living right off of the same Life that's in there, but still it's a lemon. See? That's right. "The fruits, you're known," Jesus said. And so then we find out…[8]


    1. William Branham, 54-0103M - Questions And Answers #1, para. 152
    2. William Branham, 59-1216 - What Is The Holy Ghost?, para. 31
    3. William Branham, 62-0727 - We Would See Jesus, para. 8
    4. William Branham, 63-0317M - God Hiding Himself In Simplicity, Then Revealing Himself In The Same, para. 245
    5. William Branham, 64-0125 - Turn On The Light, para. 147
    6. William Branham, 64-0213 - Then Jesus Came And Called, para. 21
    7. William Branham, An Exposition Of The Seven Church Ages - Chapter Five - The Pergamean Church Age, para. 169-2
    8. William Branham, 65-1127B - Trying To Do God A Service Without It Being God's Will, para. 30